Industry guides
Toronto contractors: winning renovation leads (HomeStars, permits and proof)
How GTA renovation contractors can balance HomeStars with their own leads, and show the licence, permit and insurance proof Toronto homeowners look for.
Toronto renovation contractors win more leads by combining two things: a presence where GTA homeowners already compare contractors, such as HomeStars, and a lead source they own, built on their website, Google Business Profile and search ads. What turns those leads into signed contracts is proof. Careful Toronto homeowners look for the City's Building Renovator licence, permits pulled in the contractor's or owner's name, insurance, WSIB status and reviews they can verify. Contractors who put that proof up front close more of the leads they already get.
HomeStars: what it's good for, and its limits
HomeStars is a review site and marketplace for home improvement pros, founded in Toronto in 2006 and acquired by IAC, then the parent of HomeAdvisor, in 2017. Many GTA homeowners check it before hiring.
How it works for contractors, in broad terms:
- Your profile shows reviews and a Star Score. According to NiceJob, a review-software company, the Star Score reflects the average quality of your reviews, how recent they are and how quickly you respond to leads.
- Paid accounts receive lead opportunities. NiceJob reports HomeStars' own claim that paid accounts can expect at least 2 to 4 leads a month, with high-scoring companies getting many more.
- HomeStars doesn't publish contractor pricing openly, so ask their sales team for the full cost, contract length and how leads are shared.
Strengths: homeowners trust a third-party review platform, and a strong Star Score reassures people who found you elsewhere.
Limits:
- You don't control the platform. Pricing, rules and lead volume can change.
- If a lead goes to several contractors at once, you're in a price race. Ask how leads are distributed before you sign.
- The homeowner's relationship starts on someone else's site.
The practical approach: treat HomeStars as one channel and as a source of proof, not as your whole pipeline. Track cost per signed contract from it, the same way you would for any other source.
Build leads you own
Your Google Business Profile
For "kitchen renovation Etobicoke" or "basement contractor North York", the map results often get the first click. Keep your profile complete, with your service area, real project photos and a steady flow of reviews. Reply to every review.
Project pages on your website
GTA homeowners want to see work like theirs, nearby. One page per project type (basement, kitchen, bathroom, addition, whole-home) with real photos, the scope, the timeline and the neighbourhood is worth more than any slogan. Add a short quote form that asks for postal code, project type, budget range and timeline, so you can qualify before driving across the city.
Search ads, used carefully
Renovation leads are expensive. LocaliQ's 2025 benchmarks for US home services put the median cost per lead at $165.67 USD for general construction and contractors, with a low 2.61% conversion rate. No equivalent Canadian figures are published, so treat these as an order of magnitude. That's why search ads work best when they point to the specific project page, target the areas you actually serve, and send every lead into a follow-up process.
Houzz and other platforms
Houzz Pro's Canadian pricing page lists single-user software plans between $99 and $279 a month (the page showed two sets of prices when we checked), with advertising packages starting at $685 a month as a separate add-on. As with HomeStars, judge it by signed contracts, not by profile views.
The proof Toronto homeowners check
A homeowner spending $60,000 on a basement is nervous. Make the checks easy.
The City of Toronto Building Renovator licence
The City requires a Building Renovator licence for businesses that repair or renovate buildings, including any business that advertises renovation services. According to the City, the total fee for a new licence is $495.12, plus a $79.65 trade examination where it applies, and renewal is $293.14 a year. The application involves criminal record checks and a health and safety declaration.
Put your licence number on your website, quotes and truck. Many competitors don't, and homeowners notice.
Building permits
Under Ontario's Building Code Act, the City says a permit is required for most construction, demolition, additions and major renovations. Homeowners can search the status of permit applications on the City's website.
Turn that into an advantage:
- Explain in your quote which parts of the project need a permit and who will apply.
- Include permit timelines in your schedule.
- Show past projects where you handled permits and inspections.
Contractors who suggest skipping permits to save time lose careful clients, and those are usually the best ones.
WSIB clearance
Ontario's WSIB policy requires a principal who directly hires a contractor for construction work to obtain a clearance certificate, with an exception for householders hiring for exempt home renovation work on their own residence. Even when the homeowner is exempt, showing a current clearance certificate signals that you run a legitimate operation. For commercial clients, it's required.
Insurance and warranty
Have a current certificate of liability insurance ready to send. Explain your workmanship warranty in writing: what it covers, for how long, and how to make a claim.
Reviews with substance
Ask clients for reviews that mention the project type and neighbourhood. "Basement finished on time in Leslieville, permits handled" helps the next homeowner more than "great job".
Handle leads like they cost $165
Because they might. A lead that waits two days for a callback is often already talking to someone else.
- Respond within minutes during business hours, and send an automatic acknowledgement after hours with a realistic callback time.
- Qualify early: area, project type, budget range, timeline, whether drawings or permits exist.
- Book a site visit quickly for qualified leads.
- Follow up after every quote at set intervals. Renovation decisions take weeks.
- Track the source of every signed contract: HomeStars, Google, referral, Houzz, repeat client.
After six months, you'll know which channel produces signed work at the lowest cost, and you can stop paying for the ones that don't.
When not to buy more leads
If you're booked months ahead, don't. Raise your prices, focus on the project types you do best, or build a waiting list. And if your close rate on quotes is low, fix the quoting and follow-up process before paying for more opportunities.
Where PNE helps
PNE's lead generation service builds the owned side of this system: project pages, quote forms that qualify, search campaigns and the follow-up that stops leads going cold. For an example of the full chain, see the Kaltico project, a construction and consulting firm in Quebec, where a new website, landing pages and automated CRM follow-up replaced a pipeline where enquiries used to sit unanswered.
Sources
- Building Renovator licence — City of Toronto
- Apply for a building permit — City of Toronto
- Clearance certificate: construction — WSIB Ontario
- How to get HomeStars reviews and grow your service business — NiceJob
- HomeStars — Wikipedia
- Search Ad Benchmarks for Home Services (2025) — LocaliQ
- Houzz Pro pricing — Houzz