CRM & sales
Online reviews and the Competition Act: fake reviews, incentives and what's allowed in Canada
What Canada's Competition Act says about fake reviews, staff reviews, incentives and review gating, the penalties involved, and how to automate requests safely.
In Canada, the Competition Act prohibits any business from making a false or misleading representation to promote itself, and the Competition Bureau treats fake reviews, undisclosed employee reviews and reviews bought from third parties as exactly that. You can ask every customer for an honest review, you can reply to reviews, and you can automate the request. What gets businesses into trouble is writing or buying reviews, letting staff or relatives post without disclosure, paying for positive ratings, and showing a curated picture of your reputation as if it were the whole one. Google's own rules are stricter still: no incentives at all, and no asking only happy customers.
This article is about the legal side. If you want the practical playbook for collecting more reviews, see our guide on how to get more Google reviews.
What the law actually says
There is no section of the Competition Act titled "reviews." The rules come from the general deceptive marketing provisions, which the Bureau has applied to reviews for more than a decade.
Section 74.01 (civil). A business engages in "reviewable conduct" when, to promote a product or any business interest, "by any means whatever," it makes a representation to the public that is false or misleading in a material respect. Courts look at the general impression a representation gives, not just its literal words.
Section 52 (criminal). The same conduct, done "knowingly or recklessly," is a criminal offence. On indictment, the fine is at the court's discretion and prison terms of up to 14 years are possible. On summary conviction, the maximum is a $200,000 fine, a year in prison, or both.
Section 74.02 (testimonials). You can't publish a testimonial without the person's written approval, and what you publish must match what they actually said. Trimming a mixed comment down to its single glowing sentence can breach this rule.
The Bureau explained why reviews fall under these rules in its Deceptive Marketing Practices Digest: consumers assume a review reflects "the authentic experiences and opinions of impartial consumers." A review written by an employee, a paid stranger, or someone who never used the product breaks that assumption, even if the opinion in it is honest. The Bureau calls these "material connections," and what matters is whether they are disclosed.
The penalties are not symbolic
Under the civil track, a corporation faces an administrative monetary penalty of up to the greater of $10 million ($15 million for each repeat violation) and three times the benefit it got from the deceptive conduct. If that benefit can't be reasonably calculated, the alternative is 3% of the corporation's annual worldwide gross revenue. For individuals, the ceiling is the greater of $750,000 ($1 million for repeat violations) and three times the benefit. A court can also order you to stop and to publish a correction.
The Act also allows any person to apply to the Competition Tribunal for leave to bring a deceptive marketing case under section 74.1. In other words, enforcement no longer depends only on the Bureau deciding to act; a competitor can try too.
Cases that involved reviews
The Bureau's published cases show how this plays out in practice:
| Year | Business | What happened | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2015 | Bell | Some employees posted reviews that appeared to come from independent customers | $1.25 million penalty and an enhanced compliance program |
| 2021 | FlightHub | Hidden fees, false price claims, and positive reviews written by the company | $5 million from the company plus $400,000 from each of two directors |
| 2023 | Amp Me | False "free" claims and purchased positive reviews | $310,000 paid toward a $1.5 million penalty, plus $40,000 in investigation costs |
In January 2024, the Bureau went further and warned that businesses "could be liable" for reviews posted by their employees without a clear disclosure of the connection.
What you can and can't do
Fake and purchased reviews
Writing reviews yourself, posting under fake names, buying reviews from a "reputation" or SEO service, or posting negative reviews on a competitor's profile are all off the table. The Bureau's Digest named these practices specifically, including companies that hire firms which pay third parties to post reviews. There's no safe version.
Reviews from employees, friends and family
The Bureau's advice from its 2024 warning:
- Train employees to disclose their connection when they review your business or a competitor.
- If the connection can't be clearly disclosed in the review, they shouldn't post it. A bare star rating is the classic example, since there's nowhere to say "I work here."
- Have a compliance program and a way to spot misleading reviews.
In practice, the simplest rule is that staff and family don't review the business on Google at all. Google's policy treats reviews from current or former employees, and from competitors, as a conflict of interest, and will remove them.
Incentives
This is where the law and the platforms differ, and where most owners get confused.
- Under the Competition Act, an incentive (a discount, a gift card, a contest entry) creates a material connection between you and the reviewer. The Bureau's influencer guidance lists free products, discounts and payments as material connections that must be disclosed clearly. An undisclosed incentivized review risks being misleading.
- Under Google's policy, disclosure doesn't save it. Google prohibits reviews "paid for, directly or in kind," including discounts or free goods offered for a review, or for changing or removing a negative one.
So on Google, the answer is simple: no incentives. On your own website or on platforms that allow disclosed incentives, any reward must be offered regardless of whether the review is positive, and the review must clearly say it was incentivized. Most small businesses are better off not offering incentives anywhere, because the extra reviews rarely justify the risk and the admin.
Review gating
Review gating means sending a "how did we do?" survey first, then asking only the happy customers to post publicly while routing unhappy ones to a private form. Many review tools used to offer this as a feature.
Google prohibits it: businesses may not "selectively solicit positive reviews from customers" or discourage negative ones. On the legal side, the risk is more about how you use the results. If you filter out unhappy customers and then advertise "4.9 stars from our clients," the general impression is that the rating reflects your clients overall, which it doesn't. That's the kind of claim the general impression test exists for.
A private feedback survey is fine on its own. What matters is that every customer also gets the same invitation to review you publicly.
Testimonials on your website
Quotes on your site are testimonials under section 74.02. Get written approval (an email saying "yes, you can use this" works), keep it on file, and don't edit the quote in a way that changes its meaning. If the person received anything from you, such as a free service, say so next to the quote.
Responding to and removing reviews
You can reply to any review, and you can report reviews that break the platform's rules. What you shouldn't do is offer a refund or discount in exchange for removing or changing a negative review. Google lists this specifically as prohibited, and a "cleaned-up" rating built that way misleads future customers.
How to automate review requests safely
Automation is where many businesses accidentally cross the line, because a tool's default settings make the decision for you. A setup that stays on the right side:
- Trigger on a completed job, not on a score. The request goes out when a job is closed, an invoice is paid, or an appointment is marked complete. Every customer gets it.
- Same message for everyone. No different wording for customers who rated you highly in an internal survey.
- No reward in the message. Not even "enter our draw."
- One reminder, then stop. Two messages are a request; five are pressure, and in Canada commercial texts and emails also have to follow anti-spam rules on consent and unsubscribe.
- Keep staff out of it. Don't let the system send review links to employees, contractors or family members.
- Turn off gating features. Check the settings in your CRM or review tool for anything labelled "smart routing," "sentiment filter" or "only send to promoters."
- Log what you send. If a complaint ever comes up, a record showing every customer got the same request is your best evidence.
If you want an internal satisfaction score as well, run it as a separate message that doesn't control who gets the public review link.
Where PNE fits
Our sales automation and CRM service often includes review requests as one step in a client's pipeline: triggered by a completed job, sent to every customer, with a single reminder and no gating rules. It's a small piece of a CRM setup, but it's one where getting the configuration right protects the business as much as it helps it.
Sources
- Competition Act (R.S.C., 1985, c. C-34) — Justice Laws Website
- Use of tests or testimonials — Competition Bureau Canada
- Deceptive Marketing Practices Digest, Volume 1 — Competition Bureau Canada
- Online reviews posted by employees: businesses could be liable — Competition Bureau Canada
- Deceptive marketing practices: cases and outcomes — Competition Bureau Canada
- Influencer marketing and the Competition Act — Competition Bureau Canada
- Prohibited and restricted content — Google Maps User Contributed Content Policy