Websites
Law 25 vs PIPEDA: what Canadian businesses outside Quebec need to know
How Quebec's Law 25 differs from PIPEDA, when it can reach a business based in Ontario or the West, and a practical checklist for serving Quebec clients.
If your business is outside Quebec, your main privacy law is still PIPEDA (or Alberta's or British Columbia's own private-sector law). Quebec's Law 25 matters when you carry on business in Quebec: you sell to, market to or collect personal information from Quebec residents as part of your regular activity. In that case, assume both regimes apply and build to the stricter one, which is usually Quebec's. Law 25 asks for more on your website, more paperwork and carries far higher penalties. The good news is that one well-designed setup can satisfy both.
The two laws in one paragraph each
PIPEDA (the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act) is the federal law for private-sector organizations that collect, use or disclose personal information in commercial activity. It applies across most of Canada. Alberta, British Columbia and Quebec have private-sector laws that the federal government has declared substantially similar, so organizations operating entirely within those provinces are generally exempt from PIPEDA for in-province activity. PIPEDA still applies anywhere when personal information crosses provincial or national borders in commercial activity.
Law 25 is the 2021 Quebec statute that modernized the Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector. It applies to personal information that a person collects, holds, uses or shares "in the course of carrying on an enterprise." Its new obligations came into force in stages between September 2022 and September 2024, with data portability arriving last, on September 22, 2024.
When Law 25 applies to a business outside Quebec
The Quebec act does not say "this law applies only to businesses located in Quebec," and it does not draw a precise line for out-of-province companies either. Its scope is tied to carrying on an enterprise, not to where your head office sits. That leaves room for interpretation, so here is a practical way to sort yourself:
- Very likely in scope: you have a location, staff or a sales rep in Quebec; you run ads targeted at Quebec; you have a French-language site aimed at Quebec customers; a meaningful share of your clients live there.
- Grey zone: you sell online across Canada, and Quebec customers buy from you like anyone else, without specific targeting.
- Probably out of scope: a Quebec resident occasionally contacts you, and you do not market there.
If you are in the first two groups, treat Law 25 as applying to that part of your business. If the stakes are high (health data, large customer files, a planned expansion into Quebec), get a privacy lawyer's opinion. This article is general information, not legal advice.
Side by side
| Topic | PIPEDA | Quebec Law 25 |
|---|---|---|
| Who is responsible | The organization must designate someone accountable for compliance | The person with the highest authority (often the owner or CEO) is the person in charge by default and can delegate in writing |
| Publishing that person | Contact information for privacy questions should be available | The title and contact details must be published on your website |
| Consent | Must be meaningful; express consent generally needed for sensitive information or uses outside reasonable expectations | Must be manifest, free, informed and given for specific purposes, asked separately for each purpose in plain language |
| Website tracking | Covered by general consent and openness principles | You must tell people before using technology that can identify, locate or profile them, and how to turn those functions on |
| Privacy policy | Openness principle: policies must be readily available | A confidentiality policy in clear, simple language must be published on the website when you collect information by technological means |
| Breaches | Report to the federal Privacy Commissioner and notify people when there is a real risk of significant harm; keep records of all breaches for two years | Notify the Commission d'accès à l'information and affected people when there is a risk of serious injury; keep an incident register |
| Sending data outside the province | Accountability for data you transfer to service providers | A privacy impact assessment and written agreement before communicating personal information outside Quebec |
| Data portability | Not a stand-alone right | Since September 22, 2024, people can ask for their computerized data in a structured, commonly used format |
| Penalties | Fines up to $100,000 for knowingly breaking certain rules (such as breach reporting) | Administrative penalties up to $10 million or 2% of worldwide turnover; penal fines up to $25 million or 4% |
The three differences that change your day-to-day work
Your website has more to show
Under Law 25, your site is part of your compliance. A visitor should be able to find:
- the title and contact details of your person in charge of personal information;
- a confidentiality policy written in plain language, not legal boilerplate;
- a clear notice before tracking tools that can identify or profile them are used, with a way to switch those functions on.
For many businesses, that last point is the cookie banner and the way analytics and ad pixels are loaded. A banner that only says "we use cookies" with an OK button does not do the job if your tags fire before anyone chooses.
Sending data to your tools counts
Most small businesses send customer data outside Quebec without thinking about it: a CRM hosted in the United States, an email platform, cloud storage. Under section 17 of the Quebec act, before personal information leaves Quebec, a privacy impact assessment must consider the sensitivity of the information, the purposes, the protection measures (including contracts) and the legal framework where it is going. The transfer then needs a written agreement. For a small firm this can be a short, proportionate document, but it has to exist.
The penalties are in a different league
PIPEDA's fines (up to $100,000 for certain knowing offences) are real but modest. Quebec's are not. The Commission d'accès à l'information can impose administrative monetary penalties of up to $10 million or 2% of worldwide turnover, whichever is greater, and penal fines for businesses run from $15,000 up to $25 million or 4% of worldwide turnover. Few small businesses will face the maximum, but the numbers explain why Quebec clients and partners now ask about privacy in procurement.
A checklist for out-of-province businesses with Quebec clients
Build once to the stricter standard:
- Map your data. List what you collect (forms, bookings, payments, CRM, email lists), where it is stored and which vendors touch it.
- Name a person in charge. Put the title and a contact email on your website.
- Rewrite your privacy policy in plain language, in French and English if you serve Quebec. Say what you collect, why, who receives it and how to reach you.
- Fix your consent flow. Ask separately for separate purposes. A contact form should not quietly sign people up to a newsletter.
- Control tracking. Make sure analytics and ad tags wait for consent where required, and that the banner offers a real choice.
- Assess vendors outside Quebec. Keep a short assessment and a contract for each tool that stores Quebec clients' data.
- Set up an incident process. Who decides if a breach is serious, who notifies the regulator(s) and where the register lives. Under PIPEDA you must keep records of every breach for two years, whether or not you report it.
- Plan for access and portability requests. Know how you would export one person's data from your CRM in a usable format.
When you do not need to do all of this
If you have no Quebec customers and do not market there, PIPEDA (or your provincial law) is your baseline. Its principles (accountability, identifying purposes, consent, limiting collection, safeguards, openness, access) are still worth meeting properly, and they overlap with most of the list above.
How this connects to your website
Most of the visible work sits on your site: the privacy page, the person-in-charge contact, consent for tracking and forms that collect only what you need. When PNE Solutions builds a site through our website design service, those pieces are planned into the build in both languages, rather than added later as a plug-in banner.
Sources
- PIPEDA in brief — Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada
- Summary of privacy laws in Canada — Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada
- What you need to know about mandatory reporting of breaches of security safeguards — Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada
- Guidelines for obtaining meaningful consent — Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada
- Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act — Justice Laws Website
- Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector (P-39.1) — LégisQuébec
- Principaux changements apportés par la Loi 25 — Commission d'accès à l'information du Québec