Ads & SEO
Do Google's AI answers cut your website traffic? What to do about it
What the research says about AI Overviews and clicks, which searches lose traffic and which hold up, and how to adapt your service pages and tracking.
Yes, for some searches. When Google shows an AI Overview, people click fewer regular results: Pew Research Center found users clicked a result in 8% of visits with an AI summary versus 15% without one, and Ahrefs measured a 58% lower click-through rate for the top result on keywords with an AI Overview. The losses are concentrated on informational, question-style searches. Short, high-intent searches for a local service are much less likely to trigger a summary in the first place. So the fix for most service businesses isn't panic. Move your effort from generic "how to" content toward service pages, your Google Business Profile and lead tracking, and judge SEO by calls and quote requests rather than raw traffic.
What the research actually says
Three sources are worth knowing, because they don't fully agree.
Pew Research Center (2025). Pew tracked the real browsing of 900 US adults through March 2025. On Google results pages with an AI summary, people clicked a traditional result in 8% of visits; without a summary, 15%. Links inside the summary itself got clicked in only 1% of visits. People were also more likely to end their browsing session altogether after a page with a summary (26% versus 16%).
Ahrefs (updated February 2026). Ahrefs compared 150,000 keywords that show an AI Overview with 150,000 informational keywords that don't, using aggregated Search Console data. For the top-ranking page, the average click-through rate on AI Overview keywords was 58% lower than expected, comparing December 2023 with December 2025. Its first version of the study, a year earlier, measured 34.5%, so the effect appears to have grown.
Google (August 2025). Liz Reid, head of Google Search, wrote that total organic click volume from Search to websites had been "relatively stable year-over-year," that clicks were of slightly higher quality (fewer quick bounces back), and that traffic was shifting between types of sites, with some losing and others gaining. Google disputes third-party reports of dramatic declines.
These can all be partly true. Total clicks across the web may hold up while specific kinds of pages, especially ones that answer simple questions, lose a large share.
Which searches lose clicks, and which don't
Pew's data shows what triggers a summary:
| Type of search | Share that produced an AI summary |
|---|---|
| One or two words | 8% |
| Ten words or more | 53% |
| Starting with who, what, when or why | 60% |
| Full sentences (noun and verb) | 36% |
| All searches studied | About 18% |
That gives a practical way to sort your own traffic.
Searches most exposed
- Definitions and explanations: "what is a heat pump," "how does a home inspection work."
- Simple factual questions: "how long does a roof last," "do I need a permit for a deck."
- Long, conversational questions that a summary can answer in a paragraph.
If your blog brought in lots of visitors with questions like these, expect fewer of them. Many of those visitors were never going to call you anyway.
Searches that hold up better
- Short service searches with local intent: "emergency plumber Laval," "commercial cleaning Quebec City." These are short, and the people typing them want to hire someone, not read.
- Brand searches: someone typing your company name.
- Comparisons and decisions where the person needs to see your prices, your work and your reviews before choosing.
- Searches where a first-hand perspective matters: Google itself says traffic is shifting toward content with first-hand experience.
How to adapt your website
Treat service pages as your main SEO assets
For a service business, the pages that matter are the ones that sell: one page per service, and per area if you serve several. Make each one hard to summarize away:
- Real prices or price ranges, and what drives them.
- Your process, step by step, with timelines you actually keep.
- Photos of your own work and short case examples.
- Specific answers to objections: warranties, permits, what happens if something goes wrong.
- A clear next step: call, book or request a quote, visible on a phone.
An AI summary can define "drain cleaning." It can't show your before-and-after photos, your reviews or your Saturday availability.
Keep doing the fundamentals Google asks for
Google's guidance for site owners is blunt: there are no extra requirements and no special optimizations for appearing in AI Overviews or AI Mode. You don't need new AI text files or special schema markup. To be eligible as a supporting link, a page must be indexed and eligible to show with a snippet. The usual basics apply: crawlable pages, helpful content and following Search policies.
You can limit what Google shows from a page with nosnippet, max-snippet or noindex, but for most small businesses that trades visibility for very little. Being cited in a summary is better than not being there.
Rethink your blog
Keep writing, but change the target. Articles that answer a question nobody else can answer as well as you do are worth more than generic explainers:
- what a typical project costs in your area and why;
- mistakes you see clients make and how to avoid them;
- comparisons between options you install or provide, with your honest view.
Each of these should link to the matching service page.
Don't ignore Google Maps
For local services, a lot of the action happens in the map results, not the blue links. Google says local ranking is based mainly on relevance, distance and prominence, and that prominence depends partly on reviews and ratings. A complete Business Profile, steady recent reviews and replies to those reviews are work that no AI summary replaces.
Measure the right thing
If your traffic drops but your calls and form submissions don't, you lost visitors who weren't buyers. That's not a problem.
Set up your reporting so you can tell the difference:
- Track conversions, not just sessions: calls from the site, quote forms, bookings.
- Use Search Console. Google says traffic from AI features is included in the Performance report under the "Web" search type. Watch impressions and clicks by page and by query.
- Compare page types. Split your informational articles from your service pages. If service-page clicks are stable and only articles are down, your sales pipeline is probably fine.
- Look at lead quality, not only volume. Ask new clients how they found you.
When to worry
- Service-page clicks and leads are falling, not just blog traffic.
- Competitors are showing up as sources in AI Overviews for your core services and you never are.
- Your Google Business Profile views and calls are dropping at the same time.
Any of those means the problem goes beyond AI summaries and needs a proper SEO review.
Where PNE fits
Our digital marketing service covers SEO and local SEO with this approach: service pages built to convert, a Google Business Profile that stays current, and reporting that ties search to actual leads. If your site's service pages are thin, that's usually the first thing we fix.
Sources
- Google users are less likely to click on links when an AI summary appears in the results — Pew Research Center
- Update: AI Overviews Reduce Clicks by 58% — Ahrefs
- AI Overviews Reduce Clicks by 34.5% — Ahrefs
- AI in Search is driving more queries and higher quality clicks — Google
- AI features and your website — Google Search Central
- Tips to improve your local ranking on Google — Google Business Profile Help