← All articles

Industry guides

Delivery apps vs your own online ordering: the commission math

What Uber Eats and DoorDash really cost per order in Canada, what direct online ordering costs instead, and how to move your regulars over without losing them.

5 min read

On a $40 delivery order, a delivery app in Canada typically keeps between $8 and $12 in commission, depending on the plan. The same order placed through your own online ordering costs about $1.42 in card processing for pickup, plus a delivery fee if you use an on-demand courier, which you can often pass on to the customer. Delivery apps are worth paying for when they bring you customers you'd never reach otherwise. They're expensive when they take a cut of orders from regulars who already know you. The goal for most restaurants isn't to leave the apps, but to move repeat customers to direct ordering and let the apps do what they're good at: discovery.

What the apps charge in Canada

Here are the published Canadian marketplace plans at the time of writing. These are the percentages taken from the order subtotal.

Platform and planDelivery commissionPickup commission
Uber Eats Lite20%10%
Uber Eats Plus25%10%
Uber Eats Premium30%10%
Uber Eats self-delivery (your own drivers)15%10%
DoorDash Basic20%10%
DoorDash Plus25% (27% on DashPass delivery orders)8%
DoorDash Premier29%8%

Some notes that matter when you read the table:

  • Uber Eats says its 10% pickup fee applies only with validated in-store pricing. Without it, pickup costs 15%.
  • On Uber Eats self-delivery, using Uber's network for farther or unstaffed deliveries adds 25%.
  • DoorDash says its partnership plans include payment processing, so there's no separate card fee on top of the commission.
  • Higher tiers come with more marketing and visibility features; DoorDash Premier, for example, includes a CA$50 marketing rebate when you spend CA$100 or more on marketing in a month. You're paying for reach, not just delivery.

What direct ordering costs

When customers order through your own website or app, you pay card processing on each order instead of a commission. A few published Canadian rates:

  • Square: 2.8% + 30¢ for online card payments, plus an extra 1.5% on cards issued outside Canada.
  • Uber Eats Webshop (Uber's tool for your own ordering site): 2.9% order processing.
  • DoorDash Online Ordering: no monthly software fee and no commission; payment processing fees apply.

If you want delivery without your own drivers, on-demand courier services fill the gap:

  • DoorDash Drive On-Demand: a flat $6.99 to $10.99 per delivery, no commission.
  • Uber Direct: no commission, priced by distance.

Many restaurants charge the customer a delivery fee that covers most or all of that courier cost.

The math on a single order

Take a $40 order (subtotal before tax and tip).

ScenarioWhat you payWhat you keep
Uber Eats Plus, delivery (25%)$10.00$30.00
DoorDash Premier, delivery (29%)$11.60$28.40
Uber Eats, pickup (10%)$4.00$36.00
Direct order, pickup, Square online rate$1.42$38.58
Direct order, delivery by DoorDash Drive, no fee passed on$8.41 to $12.41$27.59 to $31.59
Direct order, delivery by DoorDash Drive, $5 delivery fee charged$3.41 to $7.41$32.59 to $36.59

Two conclusions jump out:

  1. Pickup is where direct ordering wins biggest. Paying 10% to an app for a customer who walks in to collect their own food is the most expensive habit to break.
  2. Direct delivery isn't automatically cheaper. If you absorb the full courier cost, it can land near an app's commission. The savings come from charging a reasonable delivery fee and from keeping the customer relationship.

The math on a month

Say you do 400 app orders a month at an average of $40, on a 25% plan. That's $16,000 in sales and $4,000 in commission.

Now say 30% of those orders come from regulars who live nearby, and you convert them to direct pickup. That's 120 orders a month:

  • Commission on those 120 orders through the app: 120 × $10 = $1,200
  • Processing on those 120 orders direct: 120 × $1.42 = $170.40
  • Monthly difference: about $1,030, or more than $12,000 a year.

Your numbers will differ, but run them. Your platform reports show order counts and average ticket, and you can usually tell which customers order repeatedly.

The hidden costs of direct ordering

Direct ordering isn't free money. Budget for:

  • The ordering system. Some tools have no monthly fee; others charge a subscription. Factor it into the per-order math.
  • Menu upkeep. Prices, photos, sold-out items and modifiers have to stay current in one more place. Tools that sync with your point of sale save hours.
  • Marketing. The apps bring traffic. Your own channel only gets orders if people know about it.
  • Customer service. Missing items and late deliveries are now your problem, not the platform's support team.
  • Delivery logistics, if you go beyond pickup.

When the apps are worth it

Delivery apps earn their commission when they:

  • bring in new customers who've never heard of you;
  • cover areas or hours you couldn't serve with your own staff;
  • fill slow periods with orders you wouldn't otherwise get;
  • let you test a delivery menu before investing in your own setup.

A sensible stance for many restaurants: stay on the apps for discovery, possibly on a lower tier, and build direct ordering for everyone who comes back.

How to move regulars to direct ordering

Make direct ordering easy to find

  • Put an "Order online" button at the top of your website's home page and menu page.
  • Use the same ordering link on your Google Business Profile, Instagram bio and Facebook page.
  • Make sure the ordering page works in two or three taps on a phone. If it's slower than the app, people go back to the app.

Give a real reason to switch

  • A modest price advantage, a free item on the third direct order, or a points program.
  • Exclusive items available only on your own menu.
  • Faster pickup: a dedicated shelf or window for direct orders.

Tell people at the right moment

  • In the restaurant: a counter sign or table card with a QR code to your ordering page.
  • On receipts and packaging for direct and dine-in orders.
  • By email or text, for customers who have agreed to hear from you. In Canada, commercial messages need consent under the anti-spam law, so collect it with a clear opt-in at checkout.

Before you put promotions inside app orders or price your own menu differently, read your platform agreement. Rules on in-bag marketing and price differences vary by contract and can change.

Keep the customer data

The biggest long-term advantage of direct ordering isn't the commission. It's knowing who your customers are: their names, order history and how often they come back. That's what lets you invite them to a new menu launch or a slow-Tuesday promotion. On the apps, that relationship mostly belongs to the platform.

A simple plan

  1. Pull three months of app reports: total orders, average ticket, commission paid.
  2. Estimate what share are repeat customers.
  3. Choose a direct ordering tool that syncs with your point of sale.
  4. Launch with pickup first, which has the clearest savings.
  5. Add delivery through an on-demand courier with a delivery fee once pickup runs smoothly.
  6. Review the split every month: app orders, direct orders and the commission saved.

Where PNE fits

Our website design work for restaurants puts direct ordering at the centre of the site: an ordering button on every page, a fast mobile menu connected to your ordering tool, bilingual pages where your customers need them, and tracking that shows how many orders come direct each month.

Sources

Free website review

Want a site that brings in calls?

Tell us about your business and your current site. We’ll reply with what we would change first.

Prefer to talk? Book a free 30-minute call or call (647) 388-2843.

Keep reading